How To Show Up On ChatGPT When Someone Asks For A Local Real Estate Agent: The Ultimate Guide
Table of Contents
- Why It Matters
- Introducing GEO (Generative Engine Optimization)
- My ChatGPT Experiment
- Why those names?
- How can agents get there?
- What Actually Moves the Needle
- High Impact (Worth your time)
- Low Impact (Can work, but doesn’t make a big impact)
- The Takeaway
- Looking for the best content membership and community for real estate agents?
Let’s set the scene: Someone’s planning a move. They open ChatGPT and type:
“Who’s the best real estate agent in [Your City]?”
Does your name pop up? If not—don’t panic. You’re about to change that.
Why It Matters
More and more people are asking ChatGPT questions like:
“Who’s the best real estate agent in [City]?”
“Can you recommend a local Realtor to sell my house in [Neighborhood]?”
And ChatGPT doesn’t pull names out of thin air. It references:
- Trusted public sources
- High-authority websites
- Profiles with clear local relevance
If your name isn’t showing up yet — this guide is your roadmap to change that.
Introducing GEO (Generative Engine Optimization)
If SEO is about ranking in Google, GEO is about showing up in AI-generated responses from tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity.
GEO means optimizing for the data sources and patterns these AI engines rely on—not just keyword stuffing or backlinks. It’s about feeding AI systems what they trust:
- Verified sales data (MLS-linked platforms, local transaction volume)
- Authoritative, location-specific mentions (press, award lists)
- Keyword-rich, high-quality reviews and bios
- Recency—AI favors fresh, up-to-date information
My ChatGPT Experiment
So, I decided to test it.
I opened ChatGPT and typed:
“Who is the best real estate agent in St. Pete, FL?”
In seconds, it gave me a polished list:
- David Price – 197 sales in the past 3 years, $65M in volume
- Jennifer Thayer – Luxury market leader with an average sale of $1.4M
- Jill Helgren – Known for mid-luxury expertise, $819K avg sale
- Agencies like Avalon Group Realty and Moore Creative Realty
Why those names?
So I asked ChatGPT:
“Why did you choose those agents?”
It explained that it pulls from third-party ranking platforms, MLS sales data, client reviews, and reputable local publications—all structured, high-authority sources it trusts.
How can agents get there?
Then I asked:
“How can agents show up on those lists?”
The answer?
- Be in the data pipelines AI uses (HomeLight, FastExpert, EffectiveAgents, Zillow)
- Boost transaction volume in your target city so your sales density stands out
- Collect location-rich reviews
- Get featured in credible local media or “Best of” lists
What Actually Moves the Needle
The truth? There are things you can do to optimize your chances of showing up in ChatGPT’s “best Realtor” answer… but many times, it’s simply pulling from hard stats — transaction volume, sales density in your city, and client reviews.
That means you can boost your odds with strategic actions, but without a strong sales record in your area, optimization alone can only take you so far.
High Impact (Worth your time)
These actions directly affect the structured data sources ChatGPT relies on most:
- Update MLS-linked profiles monthly on HomeLight, FastExpert, and EffectiveAgents with every closing.
- Concentrate sales in your target city/niche so your sales density stands out.
- Request reviews that mention your city and property type on Google, Zillow, and those ranking platforms.
- Pitch for local “Best Realtor” or market feature articles — these often appear word-for-word in AI-generated lists.
Low Impact (Can work, but doesn’t make a big impact)
These won’t directly push you into ChatGPT’s top picks, but they can help indirectly by fueling more transactions, reviews, and local authority over time:
- Posting local lifestyle content on social media to nurture your audience and generate referral leads.
- Publishing a blog or newsletter that deepens relationships, leading to clients who later leave keyword-rich reviews.
- Hosting community events or sponsoring causes to increase your local visibility and press potential.
- Engaging in local Facebook groups or forums to connect with potential clients who later contribute to your review volume.
The Takeaway
If ChatGPT isn’t naming you yet, it’s not about convincing it you’re great—it’s about giving it undeniable, credible, and current evidence from the sources it trusts most.
The more you feed those sources with your wins, the harder you are to ignore.
Looking for the best content membership and community for real estate agents?
At Coffee & Contracts, we give real estate agents everything they need to show up confidently online — from customizable templates and content strategies to training on how to actually attract leads (yes, even from ChatGPT).
Ready to build a brand that gets noticed and generates results?
👉 Join the membership
